It’s no secret that I’m a fan of SANS and their associated GIAC infosec certifications. Certifications aren’t worth a ton of credibility in the information security arena, but the SANS training and testing mechanisms really do ensure that students have to have some clue about the topic to pass. The courses aren’t cheap, but SANS provides less costly community and self-study options. So, people going into the certification exams are in varying training situations.
When people see my complex-looking system for passing these exams (I was a GIAC proctor, and now hold GCIH, GCFE, GCFA, GREM, and GPEN), they often ask me how they can better prepare for the exams. Even though most SANS courses cover this to some extent at night or on day 1, let’s review some best practices for succeeding at SANS certifications.
DISCLAIMER: I follow GIAC policies to the letter and I will never provide specific details about any certification exam. So don’t bother asking.
There have already been a few blogs written about the study mechanisms for GIAC exams and I will link them at the bottom as others’ methods are similar but vary a bit.
WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- GIAC tests change regularly with the SANS course material. If you tactically acquire books from a year ago, there is a good chance they will not be completely applicable to the current test. Same with your TestCheaty.ru practice tests, etc. Stick with your provided materials.
- GIAC tests are open book, open note (no electronic devices allowed). There is enough detail in them that it is very likely you will not be able to score very high without books or notes in the room with you; they’re designed that way. Minutiae matters – read, don’t skim.
- Some SANS books have no detailed index. This is for a smart educational reason – if you plan on using the books during your test (and you should) you are pretty much obligated to create your own. This forces you to actually read every page of the books while you’re preparing, and take notes. While some SANS courses have now added an index to match industry standards, creating your own with proper tabbing and references is still highly advisable for referencing speed during the exam and as a study aid.
- People’s indexing styles vary. I will show you my system and why I do it the way I do. See the links at the end for some variations. The bottom line is you need some organized way to find stuff in the books in a time crunch.
- GIAC exams are usually 3 hours long (a few some are longer or shorter) with around 115 questions. This means you have about a minute and a half per question. Unless you read quickly and your index is top notch, you will not be looking up every answer.
- SANS instructors give you tools to help. Keep those handy SANS cheat sheets for tools, commands, and operating systems they give you in the class, and bring them to the test!
- GIAC gives you two practice tests you can take at home, and they can be given to others. We’ll talk about this in more detail, but these are really important!
WHAT YOU NEED FOR THE PANCAKES INDEX SYSTEM
- The SANS books for the certification you’re going to ace…
- Some of these colorful plastic tabbies (you can buy ’em at Walgreens or Target) 5-6 colors are best…
- A fine tip permanent marker.
- A highlighter.
- Excel or something that does the same thing.
- Word or something that does the same thing.
- A color printer (or a handy Kinko’s).
THE PANCAKES INDEX SYSTEM
First, we’re going to stop procrastinating and start the giant task of indexing. Hopefully, you’ve already read through the books during class, but I’m going to presume you have not, yet. Now, some people prefer to take one of their two practice tests before they do anything else, to get an idea of where they stand. That’s fine, but due to the short supply of two whole practice tests, I prefer to take them both after studying and initially drafting an index.
Be prepared for fully reading and indexing 5-6 SANS books to take a couple full work days. Take 2-3 days off, or block at least 12-16 hours over time off on your calendar if you’re that fortunate. I read pretty quickly; you may need a bit more time if you don’t.
We are going to open up our spreadsheet software as we do this, and keep it running as we study. We are going to keep our colorful tabs and our markers handy as well.
First, we’re going to place a uniquely colored tab at the top of every book, so we can quickly grab that book in the small heap of materials we use in the testing center. So our book .1 could be red, .2 could be purple, etc. It’s usually faster to see a color than read text. My method allows for both.
Then we will begin to read.
Just because SANS books don’t have indices doesn’t mean they aren’t divided into chapters and sections. These are usually distinguished at the start of each section in a table of contents slide. They look something like *grabs random book*:
So, we usually know roughly where we are going to put our tabs. We may decide logically to add or subtract one or two. We’ll normally ignore tabbing or noting the labs, capstone book, and appendices unless they contain useful references that compliment the text.
As we read our book, we’re going to install our tabs lengthwise along the side of the book at logical points that will help us find important sections and tools. Because I’m a bit OCD, I like to use a rotating sequence of colors through the books. That way, I can quickly look for a color instead of a generic yellow or white tab. (Purple book, red tab. Yellow book, blue tab, etc, etc…)
So place a color tab of your choice at the start of the first chapter, and write on it what it is. Then, we shall read our chapter.
If we find important information like tools, definitions, or keywords in the text, we’re going to use our highlighter to (you guessed it), highlight the critical information so we see it quickly on the page. Rocket science! We are also going to index as we read. Every time we find a new definition, critical fact, command, or tool, we’re going to add it to our spreadsheet. We’re going to take our fill button in our spreadsheet program and make the first column the book.page number and book color, and the second column the specific item and the section tab color it is in.
We are going to give a little thought to how we write these items because they’re all going to go in alphabetical order at the end. For example, if we think we would look up XSS before CSS, we should make our line item XSS & CSS, instead of CSS & XSS. Or maybe we will make two entries, one for XSS and one for CSS, with the same page number and colors, just to be extra sure we can find it later.
If the items we are in all fall under one tool or subject, we might preface them with that tool so they end up in the same place once alphabetically sorted. For example, Meterpreter – priv module, and Meterpreter – Routing and Pivoting. We might put a couple word note next to a tool so we can quickly remember what it was for.
As we continue to fill our our index, we’ll start seeing a lovely, colorful list of book color and tab color develop. We now have two ways to reference any line in our index – reading the book and page number, or quickly glancing at the book and tab color.
It’s going to take a long time to read everything. Take a break when needed. Proofread your index every so often, and make sure your colors match up.
Eventually, our books will be tabbed, highlighted, and indexed in a spreadsheet from beginning to end. We’re then going to do some Office/Open-Office/Google Doc-fu. I’ll show you in Excel.
Sort by the text column alphabetically (with no headers). Your index is now an A-Z list of stuff, and a explosion of colors.
But printing this will be lots of pages, so we’re going to open up Word and make two columns…
Then copy-pasta (or import) the contents of our excel doc into that two column doc. If the lines are two long to fit in the two columns, make your font size smaller, your margins narrower, or abbreviate specific lines accordingly. We don’t want those lines to take long to read or find, anyway.
Now it will look something like this:
This is a lot more manageable. We can even print this two-sided to make our index even smaller. We still have the alphabetical list of topics, the page number, and the book and tab color code for the item. Our index should only be a max of 6-7, or four pieces of paper, printed out.
We have an index, and tabs! They look really cool!
GETTING READY TO TEST
So whether you used my index system or somebody else’s, let’s recap. You should now have:
- Read the books.
- Highlighted important facts, tools, and terms.
- Made an index you can quickly reference (if it’s over 8 pages you had better have bound and tabbed the index, too!)
- Tracked down your SANS course tool and software cheat sheets!
And now we must, alas, take the practice tests and the actual exam.
Relax. Tests make me nervous, and I like to ease myself into the first practice test. The first practice exam, I allow myself Google and the find function on my index document, neither of which I’ll have available to me on the actual exam. This practice test, I concentrate on finding topics that I missed and adding them to my index, and figuring out what SANS cheat sheets it will be a good idea to bring with me. I also use this test to gauge if there are sections I am very weak on and need to reread.
Some things to note:
- On the practice tests, GIAC will tell you the correct answer of every question you get wrong (and why it more correct than the option you selected). You will not have a great deal of time to read and consider this. If the provided answer is confusing and you’re in a time crunch, take careful notes on what topics you got wrong (and why) to study later! (Keep in mind that GIAC policy prohibits sharing test questions and answers with other people.)
- GIAC will also give you a 1-5 star score on each topic in the books when you’re done with the test. If you’re getting 2 or less stars on a section, you definitely need to re-read it and check the quality of your indexing.
- Keep track on the first test of what you have to Google or can’t find, and make sure you add it to your index or cheat sheets.
- At the end you will get a realistic percentile score. The passing score varies by exam, but is normally around 70%. I’m not sure exactly what the tolerance is, but expect your score to vary around 5% between the assorted practice tests and exam. So if you’re at say, a 73%, you’re going to want to consider studying quite a bit more before taking the second and final practice test.
I don’t ever take two practice tests in one day. I fix my index up, study sections I am weak on, and sleep on it.
The second practice test, I have a better idea what to expect. I treat it like the actual exam rules. No digital resources, just what I have printed out and my books. I take my time and look up anything I am not certain about in my books. I do continue to take a few notes when something really eludes me.
Hopefully at this point my score is pretty good. I make some final tweaks before getting another night’s rest and taking the exam at the testing center.
SHARING PRACTICE TESTS
If you happen to pass your certification exam after only using one of your practice exams, you may send your spare test to another person’s SANS account via your GIAC portal account. This is an optional but nice thing to do for people who are struggling with an exam. The SANS course alumni and advisory board mailing lists are a great place to trade or give away practice tests, or find an extra yourself if you’re still struggling after your second practice test.
ABOUT TESTING CENTERS
GIAC tests are pretty unusual in their open book / open note format. Not every approved testing center is prepared for that from a training or space perspective. I’ve certainly ended up in testing centers with no desk space or uninformed staff who tried to prohibit the use of notes. Read the GIAC testing instructions carefully in advance and be ready to verify and confirm the policy and environment with the proctors. If something beyond the proctors’ ability to help goes wrong with the test, you may need to contact firstname.lastname@example.org or file a grievance as appropriate.
OTHER PEOPLE’S GUIDES!
I recommend checking out some other lovely peoples’ guides to indexing and studying. Everybody’s learning and note-taking style is different. Perhaps you’ll find one that works for you or combine aspects of a couple.
Thank you to everyone who has successfully used my guide over the past 5 years, and shared images of your books and tabs. I really appreciate it!
(Updated June 2020 to reflect GIAC policy changes.)
35 thoughts on “Better GIAC Testing with Pancakes”
An excellent post Lesley many thanks!
Great post! I’ll be sharing it with any GIAC test first-timers in our practice.
This method is gold! Thank you for sharing it!
Hey Lesley, thx for the tip on indexing page. Great start up point for anyone who is planning to start their GIAC certification.
[…] tips dan panduan dalam melakukan indexing, saya merekomendasikan artikel yang ditulis oleh Lesley Carhart dan Digital Forensic Tips. Silahkan goolgling untuk mencari tips […]
Similar to my approach, though you are a bit more organized and rigorous. I’m usually trying to balance that level of organization and depth of study with the gazillion other things in life, but this is the way to go.
Great stuff – going to help a lot when taking a shot myself
came for pancakes.. left with indexing tips but no pancakes. 😦
Thanks for all of your direction over the years and this guide helped me successfully become GCIH certified!! Next GCIA..Take 2 🙂
[…] setup your GIAC materials for quick reference. Hacks4Pancakes has one such guide on her site found here. Good luck! 2016 Certification Goals: ITIL Foundation | MCTS: Win 7, Configuration | MTA: […]
Lesley, thank you for sharing your method. I have never taken a Sans course and have never sat for a Giac exam before. I’ve taken plenty of other exams, none of which have been open book. I’m going to take Gmon soon and am beginning the process of putting an index together. You had mentioned Tracked down your SANS course tool and software cheat sheets! what is this and where can I get it? Thanks for any help you can offer
I’ve taken close to half a dozen SANS exams and my indexes are without the color coding.
Can you help elaborate its value proposition? Is it to help you flip to that exact spot in the book rather than flipping thru the pages to find it?
Correct, and ensures you read every page completely.
[…] Hacks4Pancakes SANS Guide […]
@Brian. I believe what Leslie is talking about is the cheat sheets that come with the printed copy of your SANS Course. Once you purchase a SANS Course, you’ll get these along with your other materials.
Awesome method-I used this to take my GREM yesterday. Worked great!
One thing I would add though is include a book color tab on the front/back covers on the side and/or bottom-when you have 4 or 5 books stacked on top of each other, open in front of you, it can be hard to see the tab on top of the book to distinguish between them. I also like to keep a copy of the book index attached to either the inside front or back cover.
Lastly, anything that would be easy to create compact notes of, eg: Assembly instructions I have issues with, I made notes of on the front covers of the books for easy reference. Making your own cheat sheets is fun too.
Thanks for posting this guide! I recently took my first GIAC exam, the GCFE, and passed it with a 90%+ score. I found your tips, such as making a detailed index and simply giving each book a color, to be really helpful and they no doubt played a roll in my passing the test.
I wish this was posted years ago, great job. Another suggestion I have for helping pass your exam is to locate the audio file in your SANS portal and have it as the default audio when you start the car before a daily commute etc, really helped me memorize a lot of the methodology and content. Plus hearing Ed Skoudis talk is like smooth jazz to me at this point.
Lesley is flippin brilliant! I used this system and passed my first GIAC exam. I’m repeating it again to go for my 2nd. It works. The due diligence put into this system will reinforce the learning initiatives by rote and having it organized gives you quick access during the exam. Lesley, I owe you a stack. 😉
[…] Create your index! You can bring the books and any other hard copy materials into the exam with you. I use @hacks4pancakes method to build an index that she has detailed extensively here. […]
[…] you’re reading this and are concerned about the test, @Hacks4Pancakes guide for SANS on her website is […]
Your place is valueble for me. Thanks!…
One of the best ways to prepare GIAC GCIH exam is with Security Administration GCIH dumps questions answers with GIAC Certified Incident Handler practice test software. VceTests provides one of the best Security Administration exam dumps for GIAC students. Prepare GIAC Certified Incident Handler exam from our GCIH practice test and be certified. https://www.vcetests.com/GCIH-vce.html
Incredibly helpful, thank you mate. I’ve got the SEC560 course next week which will be followed shortly after by the GPEN. It’ll be my first SANS course, so I’m bit nervous as traditional academics and studies have always been a weak point for me.
[…] however, Hacks4Pancakes (aka Lesley Carhart) has an excellent blog post on preparing your GIAC exam index. Pay special attention to the “What You Need To Know” section! Lesley’s breakdown […]
[…] SANS training and a well-crafted index before sitting down to make an attempt. (Check out Lesley Carhart’s great post on studying and indexing too, if you have not already.) Even if you might think ‘I know all […]
[…] if you need to. After all, the exam is open book.My method of indexing was loosely based off of the Pancake method, which seems to be extremely popular. I basically wrote down the topic that was displayed in the […]
Thanks a ton for the awesome tips! I’ve passed my 2nd GIAC cert thanks to you!
[…] on how to prepare for exam:https://tisiphone.net/2015/08/18/giac-testing […]
Good tips! I passed GWEB on my 3rd attempt. One thing that I found helped me was listening to the mp3s SANS provides to review the material. I would listen while driving or at home and have the book open to jog my memory. Another thing was going through the labs again. This helped when I would come to a scenario question and I would recall “I did that lab in book 2”.
[…] https://tisiphone.net/2015/08/18/giac-testing/ If you don’t already know about Lesley Carhart (aka @hacks4pancakes), I strongly suggest you follow her. Her blog post on creating an index covers a ton of excellent information and suggestions. I routinely refer students to this post and I know for a fact that I am not the only SME who does. The section of her post with the subheading WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW remains spot on. My personal process for creating an index is somewhat different from hers, but reading her process and ideas absolutely contributed to my own. […]
[…] Hacks4Pancakes SANS Guide […]
[…] https://tisiphone.net/2015/08/18/giac-testing/ (excellent post about how to prepare for the GIAC exams) […]
[…] I used Lesley Carhart’s (@hacksforpancakes) GIAC Indexing Guide published here. […]